Dung beetle discovery revises understanding of how nature innovates

Realization that thoracic horns are built by the same gene network as wings reframes traditional ideas about emergence of 'new' traits

When studying how organisms evolve, biologists consider most traits as derived from some earlier version already present in their ancestors. Only a very few traits are regarded as truly "novel."

A normal beetle and a beetle with ectopic wings in place of its hornsView print quality image
The left image shows thoracic horns in a typical dung beetle. The right image shows the effect of reducing the expression of a gene in the wing gene network in beetles, which transforms thoracic horns into a third set of wings. Image courtesy Armin Moczek, Indiana University

Insects were wingless, then winged. Animals were blind, then had eyes.

And in biology textbooks, novelty has a strict definition: It must have no relationship to any structure found in an ancestor and no relationship to any other body part elsewhere in the organism.

By this definition, a dolphin's pectoral fins are not a novelty because they are modified forelimbs that already existed. Some experts argue that this creates a problem since it means that novelty must seemingly arise from nothing.

Now evidence has emerged -- in a study published Nov. 21 in the journal Science -- that better illuminates how new traits can evolve. And this evidence has come from an unexpected source: the small yet charismatic dung beetle.

"Dung beetles are fascinating creatures," said Armin Moczek, the study's senior author and a professor in the Indiana University Bloomington College of Arts and Sciences' Department of Biology. Among their many qualities, one structure has placed them at the forefront of discussions about novelty among researchers: their thoracic horn.

An illustration of the evolutionary origin of horns and wings, from arthropods to insectView print quality image
An illustration of the evolutionary origin of horns and wings, from arthropods to insects. The second and third thoracic sections, in green, evolved into the fore and hind wings of modern insects, respectively. By contrast, the first thoracic segment, in blue, facilitated the evolution of diverse innovations, such as horns in the scarab beetle family, which include dung beetles. Image by David Linz, Indiana University

Regarded as a textbook example of an evolutionary novelty, the thoracic horn is unique to horned beetles and appears to have no relationship to any other structure in the animal.

This view is now changing thanks to the IU-led study, featured on the journal's cover, which provides evidence that the formation of the thoracic horn is instructed by the same core network of genes that led to the evolution of insect wings: flight structures that exist on neighboring thoracic segments.

In fact, this ancient gene network predates not just wings and horns; it already existed before there were insects, and in every segment along the entire body.

"This work forces us to rethink what we mean by 'novelty,'" Moczek said. "Each insect segment possesses this gene network, and as such, it is an ancient feature of their makeup. Yet, what each segment does with this network is so strikingly variable that it can yield traits that on the surface seem to have nothing in common, like wings and horns."

To conduct the study, Moczek, along with lead authors Yonggang Hu and David M. Linz, knocked down various genes in this "wing gene network" in three species of beetle: Onthophagus sagittarius, O. taurus, O. binodis. In all three species, the researchers were surprised to find that deactivation of genes in the network significantly affected the formation not just of wings but of thoracic horns, causing them to be reduced or completely absent.

Armin MoczekView print quality image
Armin Moczek. James Brosher, Indiana University

They also showed that they could manipulate other genes and force the horns to transform into "ectopic" wings -- or extra wings on the wrong part of the body -- which provided additional evidence that thoracic horns and wings were interchangeable, alternative outputs of the same gene network.

This work also extends beyond just dung beetles and their thoracic horns.

"This body segment of insects, the first thoracic segment, is what we call a 'hotspot' of morphological innovation in insects," Moczek said. "It harbors a lot of really diverse morphological features: horns in beetles, helmets in treehoppers, lateral projects of lace bugs and many more.

"This new evidence is profound since it suggests that all of this vast diversity, all these novelties, could in fact be enabled by a single gene network that was used millions of years ago to form the flight wings on other body segments."

Hu, Linz and Moczek added that these results contribute to a growing call to re-examine the usefulness of defining morphological novelty as the absence of relatedness to other structures. Rather, this work suggests that novelty can emerge through such relatedness -- and accordingly, textbook definitions of what constitutes novelty may need to be redefined.

This research was supported by the National Science Foundation and John Templeton Foundation.

IU Research

Indiana University's world-class researchers have driven innovation and creative initiatives that matter for nearly 200 years. From curing testicular cancer to collaborating with NASA to search for life on Mars, IU has earned its reputation as a world-class research institution. Supported by $680 million last year from our partners, IU researchers are building collaborations and uncovering new solutions that improve lives in Indiana and around the globe.

Media Contact

Kevin Fryling

IU Communications

Phone: 812-856-2988

|

Email: kfryling@iu.edu

More media resources